Start free

XLY bear put spread backtest

the consumer discretionary sector fund. Buy a put near 50 delta and sell one near 25 delta, 30 to 45 days out. It pays when the price falls.

What the history shows

XLY bear put spreads were replayed on 137 entries across 100 months (2016 to 2026), averaging -43.5% a trade on the dollars committed, with a 95% interval of -60.2% to -25.4%. The interval sits below zero: over this history the average trade lost money.

Only 24% of trades won, so the result leans on the winners being larger than the losers (a profit factor of 0.35). The worst single trade lost 106% and the account's deepest fall was 99% (with 10% of the account at risk each month).

Charging an extra $0.01 a share on every option leg moves the average trade from -43.5% to -44.5%; at $0.05 it is -48.6%. The return was already at or below zero before this extra cost.

The best entry year was 2022 (+6.9% a trade) and the worst was 2026 (-100.3%). 61% of the entries come from before March 2022, when prices are estimated from daily closes with a haircut measured against real quotes; the rest use real bid and ask quotes. These are historical replays, not live quotes and not a forecast.

Out-of-sample windows

XLY bear put spreads, trailing windows ending 2026-04-08
WindowSharpeSortinoMax drawdownWin rateProfit factorPer tradeTrades
Last 3 years-3.16-2.5584%16%0.12-65.9%32
Last 5 years-1.47-1.7290%28%0.38-40.2%68
Full history-1.71-1.9099%24%0.35-43.5%137

Slippage and commission sensitivity

XLY bear put spreads, average return per trade after slippage
FillsNet return per tradeChange
Replay fills (shorts at the bid, longs at the ask)-43.5%n/a
Extra $0.01 a share on every leg-44.5%-1.0%
Extra $0.05 a share on every leg-48.6%-5.2%

Fills in the replay already sell at the bid and buy at the ask, and a commission of $0.65 a leg is included. The extra slippage rows add to that.

Year by year

XLY bear put spreads by year of entry
YearEntriesAverage per trade
20169-56.9%
201714-57.4%
201815-22.9%
201913-62.3%
202014-25.2%
202116-50.6%
202219+6.9%
202314-62.2%
202411-56.5%
20259-73.7%
20263-100.3%

Change the delta, days to expiry or wing and replay your own version on XLY.

Clone & Modify Parameters in Vesper

Common questions

What is the historical win rate of XLY bear put spreads?

24% of 137 replayed entries made money (2016 to 2026). The average trade returned -43.5% on the dollars committed and the worst lost 106%.

How much does slippage change XLY bear put spreads?

An extra $0.01 a share per leg moves the average trade from -43.5% to -44.5%, and $0.05 moves it to -48.6%. The average return was not positive at the replay's own fills.

How has XLY bear put spreads done recently?

Trailing windows ending 2026-04-08: 3 years: Sharpe -3.16, win rate 16%; 5 years: Sharpe -1.47, win rate 28%.

What is the biggest risk of XLY bear put spreads?

The worst single trade lost 106% of the dollars committed, and the account's deepest fall from a peak was 99% (with 10% of the account at risk each month). The result depends on winners outweighing losers.

Method

How these numbers were made: each strategy was priced on weekly or fortnightly entry days from January 2016 to September 2026 on real option quotes (shorts at the bid, longs at the ask, fees per leg), 30 to 45 days to expiry, about 25 delta, wings 5% away, held to expiry and settled on the underlying's close. Entries before March 2022 use daily closes with a haircut measured against real quotes. Returns are profit divided by the dollars committed. Sharpe and Sortino use one observation per entry month and are annualized with the square root of 12, with no risk-free rate. Max drawdown compounds each month's average return at the strategy's usual sizing: the full cash set aside for a cash-secured put or covered call, 10% of the account at risk each month for spreads, condors and long options. The rules have no fitted parameter, so every window is out of sample. Intervals are a month-clustered bootstrap. Slippage is charged on top of fills that already cross the spread. This is education, not a recommendation to trade anything.