Start free

TGT earnings: expected move versus actual move

Target. What TGT options priced into each of the last 12 earnings reports, and what the stock did.

What the history shows

Over 12 reports from 2023-11 to 2026-08, TGT options priced an average move of 8.3% into each report, and the stock actually moved 8.5% on average from the close before to the close after. It moved less than priced in 7 of 12 reports: no consistent lean either way.

The largest miss came on the 2024-11-20 report, when the stock moved 13.3% more than the options priced. One report like that can cancel several quiet ones, which is the risk of selling premium into earnings.

Selling that straddle at the bid before each report and holding it to its expiry made money 7 times out of 12, with an average result of -3.5% of the premium collected. A short straddle has no cap on its loss.

These are historical quotes, not a forecast of the next report.

Priced move and actual move, report by report

TGT earnings: priced move versus actual move22%2023-11-15: priced 7.9%2023-11-15: moved 17.8%23-112024-03-05: priced 7.8%2024-03-05: moved 12.0%24-032024-05-22: priced 7.1%2024-05-22: moved 8.0%24-052024-08-21: priced 7.8%2024-08-21: moved 10.3%24-082024-11-20: priced 8.7%2024-11-20: moved 22.0%24-112025-03-04: priced 8.7%2025-03-04: moved 3.0%25-032025-05-21: priced 9.1%2025-05-21: moved 5.2%25-052025-08-20: priced 9.5%2025-08-20: moved 6.3%25-082025-11-19: priced 9.7%2025-11-19: moved 2.8%25-112026-03-03: priced 8.4%2026-03-03: moved 6.7%26-032026-05-20: priced 7.9%2026-05-20: moved 3.9%26-052026-08-19: priced 7.0%2026-08-19: moved 4.3%26-08

Left bar: the move options priced. Right bar: the move that happened, shaded when it was larger.

TGT earnings reports, the move priced by the at-the-money straddle and the close-to-close move after
ReportPricedActualShort straddle
2023-11-15 (before open)7.9%+17.8%-122%
2024-03-05 (before open)7.8%+12.0%-69%
2024-05-22 (before open)7.1%-8.0%+10%
2024-08-21 (before open)7.8%+10.3%-33%
2024-11-20 (before open)8.7%-22.0%-125%
2025-03-04 (before open)8.7%-3.0%+41%
2025-05-21 (before open)9.1%-5.2%+58%
2025-08-20 (before open)9.5%-6.3%+41%
2025-11-19 (before open)9.7%-2.8%+83%
2026-03-03 (before open)8.4%+6.7%+14%
2026-05-20 (before open)7.9%-3.9%+85%
2026-08-19 (before open)7.0%+4.3%-26%

Vesper tests a rule on every week of history, not only earnings weeks; earnings timing is not a rule you can set yet.

Test a short strangle on TGT in Vesper

Common questions

How much do TGT options price for earnings?

Across the last 12 reports, the at-the-money straddle at the close before the report priced an average move of 8.3%; for the 2026-08-19 report it priced 7.0%.

How much does TGT usually move after earnings?

8.5% on average, close to close, over 12 reports. It moved less than the options priced 7 times.

Does selling a straddle before TGT earnings work?

In this history a short at-the-money straddle held to expiry made money 7 of 12 times, averaging -3.5% of the premium. The worst outcomes are large and the loss is not capped.

Method

The priced move is the midpoint of the at-the-money call and put for the first expiry after the report, at the last close before it (the report day for an after-close report), divided by the stock price. The actual move is the close after the report against that close. The short straddle sells both legs at the bid at that close, pays $0.65 a leg, and settles at the expiry close. Real end-of-day quotes only; report dates and timing come from public earnings calendars. Education, not a recommendation to trade.