Hold to expiry, close at half the credit, or close at 21 days?
Three exit rules for short puts and put credit spreads, replayed on real option quotes on QQQ, SPY and TQQQ. Pick the tickers, the structure and how far out the trade was opened, and see how each rule did per trade and per year, against what the same cash earned in T-bills.
How these numbers were made
Every week from April 2022 to October 2026 we opened one put on each ticker: the strike nearest 25 delta, on the expiry nearest 21 days out, or nearest 37 days out within 30 to 45 days. The spread adds a long put at the first listed strike at least 5% of the price below the short strike (10% on TQQQ).
Fills use the closing quotes: the put is sold at the day's closing bid, and an early exit buys it back at the closing ask on the first close where its rule triggers. A trade held to expiry settles at its intrinsic value. Broker fees are included, and an early exit pays the fees to close.
Returns are on the cash set aside: the strike for a short put, and the most the spread can lose for a spread. Per year one trade at a time runs a single position per ticker under each rule; after an exit the next trade is the first weekly entry on or after that day, and the days in between earn nothing. Per year while tied up divides the profit by the cash and the days it was actually in a trade, which assumes the freed cash went straight into another trade just as good, so it flatters every early exit.
The window holds one bear market (2022) and the recovery after it, so a rule that did well here did well in that market. Closing quotes are not the prices a trader gets in the middle of the day. Past results are not a forecast, and this page does not say which rule to use; it shows what each one did on this sample.
Questions
- Is it better to close a short put at 50% profit or hold it to expiry?
- It depends on what is measured. Closing at half the credit wins more often and frees the cash sooner, but keeps less on each win and still takes the losses that gap through the strike. The table on this page shows both rules on real quotes since 2022, per trade and per year one trade at a time, against what the same cash earned in T-bills.
- Does closing at 21 days to expiry make more money than holding?
- On a put opened 30 to 45 days out, the 21-day exit buys the put back while time value is still in it. Whether that made more per year than holding is shown in the table for each ticker group and structure, measured one trade at a time with the idle days counted.
- Should a put be sold 21 days out or 30 to 45 days out?
- This page compares both entry windows on the same weeks and tickers. It shows what each did on this sample and does not say which to use.
- Why do per year while tied up and per year one trade at a time differ?
- Per year while tied up only counts the days cash was in a trade, as if freed cash were always reinvested at once in an equally good trade. One trade at a time waits for the next weekly entry after an exit and counts the idle days as earning nothing, which is closer to what an account of that size actually made.
- How were these numbers made?
- Weekly entries on QQQ, SPY and TQQQ from April 2022 to October 2026, a 25-delta short put or a put credit spread, sold at the closing bid and bought back at the closing ask, with broker fees, settled at intrinsic value at expiry. Returns are on the cash set aside.
Strike check · Assignment playbook · Closing at 50% · The 21 DTE rule · Start free