Guide

DRIP calculator: dividend reinvestment on real fund history

Pick a fund, the month you bought and an amount, and see what the money is worth today with every payout reinvested, with the payouts taken as cash, and in the index the fund is compared with. Real month-end prices and payouts for SCHD, VYM, JEPI, QQQI, QYLD, MSTY and 12 more, not a constant-yield projection.

Short answers

Is it better to reinvest dividends or take them as cash?

For most funds we measured, reinvesting came out ahead: 10,000 in SCHD at the end of January 2016 was worth about 41,100 with payouts reinvested and about 35,100 with them taken as cash (35,100 includes the cash). It reversed for funds whose share price kept falling: 10,000 in MSTY at its first month end was worth about 10,800 reinvested but about 19,800 taken as cash, because each reinvested payout bought shares that then lost value.

How does a DRIP calculator work?

Every payout buys more shares at that day's price, so the share count grows and later payouts are paid on more shares. This calculator uses each fund's real month-end closes and actual payouts, so it shows what really happened from the month you pick, including price falls and payout cuts, instead of assuming a fixed yield and growth rate.

Does a high yield fund grow faster with DRIP?

Its share count grows faster, not necessarily its value. Reinvesting QYLD from January 2016 multiplied the share count about 3.3 times, yet 10,000 grew to about 26,900 while the same money in QQQ with dividends reinvested grew to about 70,400. A high payout reinvested into a fund whose price falls mostly replaces the shares the price took away.

The calculator

DRIP calculator: pick a fund, the month you bought, an amount and an optional monthly addition, and it shows what the money is worth with every payout reinvested, with payouts kept as cash, and in the index the fund is compared with, on real month-end prices and payouts. It runs in your browser with JavaScript on.

10,000 invested at the end of January 2016 (or the fund's first month), valued at the 2026-11-13 close:

FundBoughtWith DRIPPayouts kept as cashIndexIndex with DRIP
SCHD2016-0141,11935,055SPY46,305
QQQI2024-0115,39514,584QQQ16,542
JEPQ2022-0518,92316,759QQQ22,666
JEPI2020-0519,61217,391SPY27,103
SPYI2022-0817,58015,799SPY20,188
GPIQ2023-1018,43017,430QQQ19,708
GPIX2023-1017,73016,940SPY18,704
QYLD2016-0126,91019,290QQQ70,439
XYLD2016-0125,63720,273SPY46,305
DIVO2016-1232,34526,495SPY39,286
QDTE2024-0315,28113,407QQQ15,514
MSTY2024-0210,78919,822MSTR10,913
ULTY2024-029,6699,873QQQ15,712
NVDY2023-0529,76822,122NVDA43,180
TSLY2022-1113,24510,149TSLA20,042
CONY2023-0810,31517,769COIN16,036
VYM2016-0135,18230,442SPY46,305
O2016-0118,06916,503SPY46,305
VOO2016-0146,61642,457SPY46,305

What reinvesting did, fund by fund

10,000 bought at the end of January 2016, valued at the November 13, 2026 close. SCHD: about 41,100 reinvested, 35,100 as cash, against 46,300 in SPY reinvested. VYM: 35,200 and 30,400. XYLD: 25,600 and 20,300 against SPY's 46,300. QYLD: 26,900 and 19,300 against QQQ's 70,400. Realty Income (O): 18,100 and 16,500.

The newer funds, from their first month end: JEPI (May 2020) 19,600 reinvested against SPY's 27,100; QQQI (January 2024) 15,400 against QQQ's 16,500; GPIQ (October 2023) 18,400 against 19,700. Every income fund in the list finished behind its index with payouts reinvested; the dividend calculator has the yearly figures.

When taking the cash won

On three funds the cash beat reinvesting: MSTY (19,800 as cash against 10,800 reinvested), CONY (17,800 against 10,300) and, narrowly, ULTY (9,900 against 9,700). All three pay out a very large share of their price and their prices fell a long way. Cash taken out early was safe from the fall; reinvested cash bought shares that then dropped.

That is a feature of the path, not a rule: had MSTR kept rising, reinvesting MSTY would have won. What the numbers do show is that DRIP compounds the fund's own total return. If the fund's total return is weak, reinvesting compounds a weak return. The MSTY dividend history has the payouts behind these figures.

Reading the results

"Worth with payouts kept as cash" adds the shares' value to every payout received, with the cash earning nothing. In a real account that cash would earn interest or be spent, and taxed: a taxable account owes tax on payouts whether they are reinvested or not.

"Added every month" buys at each month-end close after the first, the way a regular contribution plan would. The index line uses the same money on the same days, so the two are directly comparable.

How we measured

Daily closing prices and distributions from Yahoo Finance through the November 13, 2026 close, split adjusted. The DRIP figures buy at a month-end close and value at the last close; reinvesting buys more shares on each ex-date, and cash kept earns nothing. Each fund is compared with what it tracks on exactly the same days. No taxes or trading costs are included, and past returns do not predict future ones. This is a measurement, not advice for anyone's account.

Measured from daily closes and distributions, every payout reinvested, each fund against its index on the same days. Past returns do not predict future ones. This is education, not a recommendation to buy or sell anything.

Test your own rule on history, free