Guide

SCHD vs VYM: returns, dividends and drawdowns, year by year since 2012

SCHD and VYM move together (daily correlation 0.96 since 2016), but they have traded the lead: SCHD won 2020 and 2026 by 14 to 18 points, VYM won 2023, 2024 and 2025, by 11 points in 2025. Every calendar year side by side, the payouts, the worst drops, and what 10,000 became in each.

Short answers

Is SCHD or VYM better?

Neither won every year. With payouts reinvested, 10,000 at the end of January 2016 became about 41,100 in SCHD and 35,200 in VYM by November 13, 2026; from January 2021 it was the other way, 20,800 in SCHD and 21,400 in VYM. VOO beat both from either start (46,600 and 22,100).

Which pays a higher dividend, SCHD or VYM?

SCHD, on the last twelve months: about 2.9% of the price against about 2.2% for VYM. SCHD's payout has also grown faster, about 10.6% a year over ten years against 5.0% for VYM, and VYM's payout was nearly flat from 2023 to 2025.

Should I hold both SCHD and VYM?

They behave much like one fund: their daily returns correlate at 0.96 since 2016, more than either does with the S&P 500 (0.85 for SCHD, 0.91 for VYM). Holding both changes little about how the money moves in a sell-off. This is a measurement, not a recommendation.

Year by year, payouts reinvested

Calendar-year total return, SCHD vs VYM, with VOO for scale: 2012: 11.4% vs 12.7% (VOO 16.0%). 2013: 32.9% vs 30.1% (32.4%). 2014: 11.7% vs 13.5% (12.9%). 2015: -0.3% vs 0.3% (1.3%). 2016: 16.4% vs 17.0% (12.2%). 2017: 20.8% vs 16.4% (21.8%). 2018: -5.6% vs -5.9% (-4.5%). 2019: 27.3% vs 24.1% (31.4%). 2020: 15.0% vs 1.1% (18.3%). 2021: 29.9% vs 26.2% (28.8%). 2022: -3.3% vs -0.4% (-18.2%). 2023: 4.5% vs 6.6% (26.3%). 2024: 11.7% vs 17.6% (25.0%). 2025: 4.3% vs 15.4% (17.8%). 2026 through November 13: 34.9% vs 16.9% (11.5%).

VYM won 8 of the 15 years and SCHD 7, mostly by a point or two. The big gaps came in 2020 (SCHD ahead by 14 points), 2025 (VYM ahead by 11) and 2026 so far (SCHD ahead by 18). From October 2011 SCHD returned about 13.8% a year, VYM 12.7% and VOO 14.9%.

Dividends: yield and growth

SCHD's payout per share (split adjusted) grew from 0.382 in 2015 to 1.047 in 2025, about 10.6% a year. VYM's grew from 2.149 to 3.501, about 5.0% a year, and almost stopped growing after 2023 (3.479, 3.495, 3.501). On the last twelve months SCHD pays about 2.9% of its price and VYM about 2.2%. Both pay quarterly, in March, June, September and December; the SCHD dividend history and VYM dividend history pages list every payout.

Worst drops

Largest fall from a high on total return: SCHD -33.4% and VYM -35.2%, both in early 2020, against -34.0% for VOO. In 2022 the dividend funds held up far better: SCHD's deepest drop inside that year was -16.8% and VYM's -15.8%, against -24.5% for VOO. That 2022 cushion is the main measured case for a dividend fund next to an index fund; 2023 and 2024, when both trailed VOO by 7 to 22 points, are the cost.

What 10,000 became

DRIP calculator: pick a fund, the month you bought, an amount and an optional monthly addition, and it shows what the money is worth with every payout reinvested, with payouts kept as cash, and in the index the fund is compared with, on real month-end prices and payouts. It runs in your browser with JavaScript on.

10,000 invested at the end of January 2016 (or the fund's first month), valued at the 2026-11-13 close:

FundBoughtWith DRIPPayouts kept as cashIndexIndex with DRIP
SCHD2016-0141,11935,055SPY46,305
QQQI2024-0115,39514,584QQQ16,542
JEPQ2022-0518,92316,759QQQ22,666
JEPI2020-0519,61217,391SPY27,103
SPYI2022-0817,58015,799SPY20,188
GPIQ2023-1018,43017,430QQQ19,708
GPIX2023-1017,73016,940SPY18,704
QYLD2016-0126,91019,290QQQ70,439
XYLD2016-0125,63720,273SPY46,305
DIVO2016-1232,34526,495SPY39,286
QDTE2024-0315,28113,407QQQ15,514
MSTY2024-0210,78919,822MSTR10,913
ULTY2024-029,6699,873QQQ15,712
NVDY2023-0529,76822,122NVDA43,180
TSLY2022-1113,24510,149TSLA20,042
CONY2023-0810,31517,769COIN16,036
VYM2016-0135,18230,442SPY46,305
O2016-0118,06916,503SPY46,305
VOO2016-0146,61642,457SPY46,305

With payouts reinvested, valued at the November 13, 2026 close. From the end of January 2016: SCHD 41,100, VYM 35,200, VOO 46,600. From the end of January 2021: SCHD 20,800, VYM 21,400, VOO 22,100. Taking the payouts as cash instead left SCHD at 35,100 and VYM at 30,400 from 2016. Switch the fund in the calculator to try another start month.

How we measured

Daily closing prices and distributions from Yahoo Finance through the November 13, 2026 close, split adjusted. The DRIP figures buy at a month-end close and value at the last close; reinvesting buys more shares on each ex-date, and cash kept earns nothing. Each fund is compared with what it tracks on exactly the same days. No taxes or trading costs are included, and past returns do not predict future ones. This is a measurement, not advice for anyone's account. The calendar-year figures use each year's last close, and correlations use daily total returns from January 2016.

Measured from daily closes and distributions, every payout reinvested, each fund against its index on the same days. Past returns do not predict future ones. This is education, not a recommendation to buy or sell anything.

Test your own rule on history, free