Guide

MSTY review: total return vs MSTR, measured

MSTY has paid out more than twice its launch price in distributions. Its share price fell about 90% over the same time. Here is what an owner actually earned against simply holding MSTR on the same days.

What MSTY is

MSTY is the YieldMax MSTR Option Income Strategy ETF. It does not own MicroStrategy (Strategy) shares outright. It builds a synthetic long position with options and sells call options against it, then pays the option premium out. It paid monthly at first and has paid every week since October 2025.

Because MSTR is one of the most volatile large stocks, the calls it sells carry very large premiums, which is where the headline yield comes from. Over the last twelve months its distributions added up to about 160% of its current share price.

The payout is not the return

From its first close on February 22, 2024 to midday November 13, 2026, MSTY paid distributions worth about 225% of its launch price. Over the same days its share price fell about 90%. Put together, with every distribution reinvested, the total return was about +25% in all, or about 8.7% a year.

MSTR itself returned about 16.9% a year on the same days, with no distributions at all. So the fund turned a stock that rose into a large stream of cash and a share price that mostly disappeared, and the sum of the two was about half of what the stock did on its own.

Year by year

2024 from launch: MSTY +200.2% against MSTR +306.1%. 2025: MSTY -42.7% against MSTR -47.5%. 2026 to mid November: MSTY -27.1% against MSTR -28.2%.

That is the shape every single-stock income fund in our data shows. In the big up year it kept about two thirds of the gain, because the calls it sold capped the rally. In the down years it fell almost as far as the stock, because the premium it collected was small next to the fall. On monthly returns MSTY caught about 77% of MSTR's up months and about 81% of its down months: more of the downside than the upside.

Why the share price keeps falling

A covered call fund gives away the part of a rally above the strike it sold, and keeps the whole of every fall. When it pays out most of what it earns, nothing is left to rebuild the price after a drop. Repeat that through a volatile stock's swings and the price ratchets down. The worst drawdown on a total-return basis was -77.4%, against -82.6% for MSTR.

The weekly payout has shrunk with the price. In 2024 a monthly payout was often 8% to 11% of the share price; in recent weeks each payout has been about 1.2% to 1.6% of a share price that is itself much lower. The yield as a percentage still looks huge, which is exactly why the yield is the wrong number to judge the fund by.

Is MSTY a good investment?

This is not advice for anyone's account. What the record says: an owner who spent every distribution has a share worth about a tenth of what they paid, and received a lot of cash on the way. An owner who reinvested everything earned about half of what MSTR returned, with a drawdown almost as deep. If the goal is exposure to MSTR, the stock did better. If the goal is income, the income has come partly from handing back the capital, and it falls when the price falls.

Two checks before buying any single-stock income fund: compare total return against the stock on the same days, never the yield, and look at the price chart since launch, because that is the part of the yield that was your own money coming back.

Selling the calls yourself

The same trade can be run by hand: own the shares and sell a covered call, or sell a cash-secured put. Our replays of puts on single stocks and leveraged funds found that the worst trades arrive as gaps through the strike, and on very volatile names they were large. The selling options on leveraged ETFs guide has those numbers, and the YieldMax ETFs review compares NVDY, TSLY, CONY and YMAX the same way.

How we measured

Daily closing prices from Yahoo Finance through midday November 13, 2026, split adjusted. Total return reinvests each distribution on its ex-date. Each fund is compared with what it tracks on exactly the same days, from the fund's first close. No taxes or trading costs are included, and past returns do not predict future ones. This is a measurement, not advice for anyone's account.

Measured from daily closes and distributions, every payout reinvested, each fund against its index on the same days. Past returns do not predict future ones. This is education, not a recommendation to buy or sell anything.

Test your own rule on history, free