Guide

Straddle vs strangle, measured on real quotes

A straddle is a put and a call at the same strike, at the money. A strangle moves both strikes out. Replayed on real bid and ask since 2022, a short strangle on SPY won 71% of the time and averaged +0.30% of the share price a trade, against 58% and +0.07% for the short straddle, with about the same worst trade.

Short answers

What is the difference between a straddle and a strangle?

Both are a put and a call on the same stock with the same expiry. A straddle uses one strike for both, at the money. A strangle puts the put below the price and the call above it. The straddle costs or pays more and reacts to any move; the strangle costs or pays less and needs the price to leave a range. On SPY, 37 days out, the straddle averaged 4.10% of the share price in premium and the 25-delta strangle 1.57%, with its strikes about 6.9% apart.

Which is better to sell, a straddle or a strangle?

On the same days in our replay, the short strangle did at least as well on average on SPY, QQQ and AAPL, won more often (71% against 58% on SPY) and had a worst trade within about a point of the straddle's. The straddle's extra premium did not pay for the extra times it lost. Both lost money over the whole window on NVDA and TSLA.

Is buying a straddle profitable?

On the index funds it was not: a long straddle on SPY lost 0.12% of the share price a trade on average and finished ahead only 41% of the time, because the premium paid at the ask was a little more than the average move (4.15% of the price against 4.0%). On NVDA and TSLA it made money over 2022 to 2026, but all of that came from 2022 to 2024; buyers lost in 2025 and 2026.

The difference in two lines

A straddle is a put and a call at the same strike, at the money, with the same expiry. A strangle is a put below the price and a call above it, here each about 25 delta. Sell either one and you collect two premiums and lose when the price moves far enough; buy either one and you pay two premiums and win when it does.

The straddle is priced at about the size of the move. On SPY, 37 days out, the straddle sold for 4.10% of the share price on average at the bid and cost 4.15% at the ask, and the average move by expiry was 4.0%. On QQQ it sold for 5.47% and cost 5.57%, against a 5.5% move. The strangle collected 1.57% on SPY with its strikes about 6.9% apart, so it kept the whole premium whenever SPY stayed inside that range.

How we tested it

We replayed 110 entry days per ticker on SPY, QQQ, AAPL, NVDA and TSLA from April 2022 to September 2026 (108 on NVDA and TSLA, where two holds spanned a split), the expiry nearest 37 days out, held to expiry. Sold legs were filled at the end-of-day bid and bought legs at the ask, with fees on every leg, and settled on the closing price at expiry. All four trades were built on the same days.

Results are a share of the stock price times 100, the value of the shares one lot controls, so the four compare on one scale. A broker holds less than that as margin on a short straddle or strangle, and how much differs by broker, so a return on margin would be a larger number with the same sign. The entries overlap, about one every ten trading days against a 37-day hold, so they describe the window well but are not 110 independent tries.

Selling: the strangle won more often for about the same worst case

SPY: the short straddle averaged +0.07% a trade and won 58% of the time; the short strangle averaged +0.30% and won 71%. QQQ: the straddle broke even (+0.00%) and won 58%, against +0.11% and 68% for the strangle. AAPL: the straddle lost -0.38% a trade and won 52%; the strangle made +0.14% and won 64%.

The worst trade was close on every index: SPY -11.0% for the straddle and -10.1% for the strangle, QQQ -11.8% and -11.0%, AAPL -15.7% and -15.6%. On SPY and AAPL both came from the same entry, the end of February 2025, which expired in the early April selloff. A move that large runs through both sets of strikes, and the extra premium the straddle collected covered little of it.

What the straddle buys with its bigger premium is a bigger best case: +5.3% of SPY's price against +2.7% for the strangle. What it gives up is the range. It starts losing as soon as the price moves more than the premium, which happened in about four entries out of ten.

Buying: the index buyer paid, the single-stock buyer was paid, for a while

Bought on SPY, the straddle lost -0.12% a trade and finished ahead 41% of the time; the strangle lost -0.34% and finished ahead 27% of the time. QQQ: -0.11% for the straddle and -0.18% for the strangle. That loss is the seller's gain, less the bid-ask spread each side pays.

NVDA and TSLA went the other way over the whole window. A long straddle on NVDA averaged +0.54% a trade and a long strangle +0.70%; on TSLA +1.59% and +1.12%. Selling them lost: NVDA -1.01% for the straddle and -0.96% for the strangle, TSLA -2.02% and -1.39%, with worst trades of -41.9% and -38.8% on NVDA and -48.6% and -39.7% on TSLA.

By year, the single-stock result flips

The NVDA and TSLA averages are three years against two. The short straddle on NVDA averaged -3.09% a trade in 2022, -3.79% in 2023 and -2.82% in 2024, then +1.53% in 2025 and +3.80% in 2026. On TSLA: -6.15%, -5.00% and -2.84%, then +1.08% and +2.87%. Options on these two were priced for less movement than showed up in the early years and for more in the later ones.

The index results held up better. The short strangle on SPY made money in every year, from +0.14% a trade in 2022 to +0.50% in 2026. The short straddle on SPY lost -0.72% a trade in 2022 and about broke even in 2025 (-0.02%).

Below the 200-day average

With QQQ under its 200-day moving average at entry (25 of 110 days), the short straddle lost -1.29% a trade and won 40% of the time; the short strangle lost -0.26% and won 64%. Above it, the straddle made +0.38% and the strangle +0.21%. On SPY below the average the straddle lost -0.55% and the strangle made +0.29%.

That is the straddle's weakness in one line: a falling index moves further, and a strike at the money has no room. The strangle's put strike gave it some.

Before you place one

A short straddle or strangle carries a naked call, which has no cap, and a put, which can lose nearly the strike. Size it by the worst trade, not the win rate: on the indexes that was about a tenth of the share value of one lot in 37 days, and on a single stock like NVDA or TSLA between two fifths and a half.

This window is four and a half years, one bear market and one fast drop, and every trade is held to expiry. Closing early at a profit or rolling changes the numbers. The shape held across all five tickers: the straddle collects more and loses more often, and the strangle trades some premium for a range.

Historical replays are not a forecast. Options can lose more than the premium collected. This is education, not a recommendation to trade anything.

Test your own rule on history, free