Guide

Yield on cost: what it measures, and what SCHD, VYM and VOO show

Yield on cost is a year of payouts divided by the price you paid. For a January 2016 buyer it is now 8.4% in SCHD, 5.7% in VYM and 4.2% in VOO, and VOO is the account with the most money in it.

Short answers

How do you calculate yield on cost?

Add up the payouts per share over the last twelve months and divide by the price you paid per share. VOO paid 7.428 a share over the twelve months to November 13, 2026, and someone who bought at 177.75 at the end of January 2016 gets 4.2% on that price, while the fund's own yield is 1.07%.

Is yield on cost the same as dividend yield?

No. Dividend yield divides the payouts by today's price, so it answers what a new buyer gets. Yield on cost divides the same payouts by the old price you paid, so it answers how your own income has grown against what you put in. The shares and the payouts are the same in both.

Does a high yield on cost mean a better investment?

Not by itself. It looks only at income and ignores what the shares are worth. From January 2016 SCHD's yield on cost reached 8.4% against VOO's 4.2%, yet 10,000 in VOO with payouts reinvested became about 46,600 and in SCHD about 41,100.

What yield on cost measures

Yield on cost takes the payouts a share has made over the last twelve months and divides them by the price you paid for it. It does not change with the market price, so it only moves when the payout moves. That is why it is a favorite of people who have held a long time: a payout that grows makes the number climb every year.

Take VOO bought at the end of January 2016 at 177.75. Over the twelve months to November 13, 2026 it paid 7.428 a share, which is 4.2% of the price paid. The fund's own yield on that day is 1.07%, because the same 7.428 is divided by 693.38. Same shares, same payouts, two honest numbers that answer different questions.

Three funds, two start dates

Bought at the end of January 2016, price paid per share (SCHD split adjusted): VOO 177.75, SCHD 12.56, VYM 64.87. The yield in the first twelve months was 2.3% for VOO, 3.3% for SCHD and 3.4% for VYM. The yield on cost now is 4.2% for VOO, 8.4% for SCHD and 5.7% for VYM. Payouts received since came to 34.5%, 63.0% and 50.2% of the price paid.

Bought at the end of January 2021, price paid: VOO 340.18, SCHD 21.19, VYM 90.99. First-year yield: 1.6%, 3.5% and 3.4%. Yield on cost now: 2.2%, 5.0% and 4.0%. Payouts received since: 10.9%, 25.1% and 21.5% of the price paid.

Put another way, 10,000 bought in January 2016 now throws off about 418 a year in VOO, 840 in SCHD and 567 in VYM, before any reinvesting. The fund yields today are 1.07%, 2.92% and 2.23%.

Why the ranking flips on total return

Ranked by yield on cost, SCHD leads VYM, which leads VOO. Ranked by the money in the account, VOO is first, even though its yield on cost is the lowest of the three. From January 2016, 10,000 with every payout reinvested was worth about 46,600 in VOO, 41,100 in SCHD and 35,200 in VYM on November 13, 2026. With the payouts taken as cash instead, the shares plus the cash came to about 42,500, 35,100 and 30,400.

The reason is where the return showed up. VOO's payout per share grew 71% from 2016 to 2025, but its price rose faster, so most of its return arrived as a higher share price instead of income. SCHD and VYM handed back more of theirs as cash, which is why their yield on cost is higher and their price gain is smaller. Yield on cost counts only the cash half, so it cannot tell you which account is worth more.

Years matter too. SCHD's 2022 was a 3.3% loss against 18.2% for VOO, but VOO was ahead by 22 points in 2023 and 13 in 2024. Yield on cost does not show any of that.

When it is useful and when it is not

It is a fair way to see how much your own income has grown against what you paid. A holding whose payout keeps rising will show a rising yield on cost, and one whose payout is flat will not: VYM's payout was 3.479 a share in 2023, 3.495 in 2024 and 3.501 in 2025, so a buyer's yield on cost has barely moved in three years.

It is a poor way to compare funds or to decide where new money goes. A new buyer pays today's price and gets today's yield, so the yield on cost of someone who bought ten years ago does not apply to them. For new money, the useful numbers are today's yield, how fast the payout has grown, and the total return. Taxes are not included on this page, and they can change the ranking.

How we measured

Daily closing prices and distributions from Yahoo Finance through the November 13, 2026 close, split adjusted, from the same month-end data that powers the reinvestment calculator. The buy is at a month-end close. The last twelve months of payouts run from the November 2025 month-end to November 13, 2026, which holds four quarterly payouts for each of the three funds. No taxes or trading costs are included, and past returns do not predict future ones. This is a measurement, not advice for anyone's account.

Measured from daily closes and distributions, every payout reinvested, each fund against its index on the same days. Past returns do not predict future ones. This is education, not a recommendation to buy or sell anything.

Test your own rule on history, free